Examines accepted methods of calculating the effect of deferred realization on the effective rate of capital gains tax paid by common shareholders. Proposes a valuation-based method that is designed for growth stocks where gains are accrued gradually and realized in lump sums.

Coyne, Fabozzi, and Yaari reply to Kiefer's comments about effective capital gains tax rates.

We argue that under the U.S. tax system, where individual investors are taxed separately from the corporations they own, cash-for-stock acquisition (CSA) is inter alia a profitable arbitrage. This argument is based on the idea that the burden of personal taxation creates a wedge between the...