In the move to adopt rights based arrangements for renewable resources to avoid the losses of open access and the inefficiencies of prescriptive regulation, we argue that grandfathering the allotments of local users can be the most efficient distribution mechanism. We differ from the standard...

This paper builds on the framework developed by Anderson and McChesney (1994) to analyze two sovereigns bargaining over the use of scarce resources. We adapt the "raid or trade" model of disputes over land to the high seas fisheries context, where sovereigns must decide whether to continue the...