Hierarchical inconsistencies : a critical assessment of justification
Juozas Kasputis
The existential insecurity of human beings has induced them to create protective spheres of symbols: myths, religions, values, belief systems, theories, etc. Rationality is one of the key factors contributing to the construction of civilisation in technical and symbolic terms. As Hankiss (2001) has emphasised, protective spheres of symbols may collapse - thus causing a profound social crisis. Social and political transformations had a tremendous impact at the end of the 20th century. As a result, management theories have been revised in order to deal with transition and uncertainty. Francis Fukuyama's (2000) approach is supportive of hierarchical organisation as the best solution when facing a "disruption". The notion of Homo Hierarchicus has been based on, allegedly, rational presumptions. This paper contributes to the discussion on hierarchy within contemporary organisations. It criticises so-called "natural" and "rational" necessities justifying hierarchy. A key issue identified by the paper is the formalisation of language in claiming value-free knowledge and "detached" observation as the basis for neutral rationality and aspired efficiency. This should be seriously reconsidered as hindering rather than aiding understanding of social complexity. All in all, Homo Hierarchicus appears to be misleading rather than helping symbolic sphere or construct.
Year of publication: |
2019
|
---|---|
Authors: | Kasputis, Juozas |
Published in: |
Economic thought. - Bristol, UK : World Economics Association, ISSN 2049-3509, ZDB-ID 2882388-6. - Vol. 8.2019, 2, p. 1-12
|
Subject: | Rationality | bureaucracy | hierarchy | complexity | Theorie | Theory | Hierarchie | Hierarchy | Bürokratie | Bureaucracy | Rationalität |
Saved in:
freely available
Type of publication: | Article |
---|---|
Type of publication (narrower categories): | Aufsatz in Zeitschrift ; Article in journal |
Language: | English |
Classification: | B50 - Current Heterodox Approaches. General ; M14 - Corporate Culture; Social Responsibility ; Z13 - Social Norms and Social Capital |
Source: | ECONIS - Online Catalogue of the ZBW |
Persistent link: https://www.econbiz.de/10012156321
Saved in favorites
Similar items by subject
-
Political rents, promotion incentives, and support for a non-democratic regime
Lazarev, Valery, (2004)
-
Tirole, Jean, (1985)
-
Hierarchy and society : anthropological perspectives on bureaucracy
Britan, Gerald M., (1980)
- More ...