Stuck in Brussels : Should transport policy be determined at EU level?

Transport policy is increasingly determined at EU level, with national, regional and local governments heavily constrained by a supranational regulatory framework. This one-size-fits-all approach has meant regulations have frequently been maladapted to local conditions, and as a result have imposed very large costs on individuals and businesses. The European Commission has wasted vast sums on ‘white-elephant’ transport projects where the costs have outweighed the benefits. EU climate change policies have imposed huge costs on the transport sector for little benefit. The biofuels requirement in petrol and diesel is costing taxpayers and consumers across the EU an estimated €20 billion a year, and harms the poor in developing countries by inflating food prices and drives deforestation by increasing the demand for products, such as palm oil. EU directives effectively prohibit full vertical integration on railways. The resulting industry fragmentation is thought to have increased costs by approximately £1.5 billion a year in the UK alone, pushing up taxpayer subsidies. A similarly flawed model is now being imposed on seaports. Rather than the top-down structures imposed by the EU, regulatory institutions should be free to evolve from the bottom up, their scale depending on market conditions rather than political diktat