The e-government paradox in post-Soviet countries
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to investigate the emergence of e-government in post-Soviet countries using Kazakhstan as a case study. Extant research on e-government in developing countries highlights significant benefits including improved public services, reduced corruption, and more open and inclusive government. The paper asserts the presence of an e-government paradox which limits its potential to improve public services. Design/methodology/approach: Primary data were collected from a number of sources: 6 focus groups with central government agencies, local authorities and civil society organisations; 25 structured and semi-structured interviews; and participant observation. Findings: The research finds evidence of an e-government paradox in five forms: an emphasis on technological development; transactional services are faster but have displaced attention from core public services; petty corruption has been reduced but grand corruption remains; isomorphic mimicry; and greater participation by citizens has been limited. Research limitations/implications: The focus of the research is Kazakhstan. Applying the lessons learned to other post-Soviet countries has limitations given their different stages of development since independence. Practical implications: The key practical implication of this research is that countries can become absorbed by e-government technology without questioning the fundamental business model which underpins how public services are delivered. Ultimately, this impacts on the social value of e-government. Originality/value: While existing research has examined how e-government has been implemented in developing countries, this paper focusses on Kazakhstan as an authoritarian state with wider implications for post-Soviet countries.
Year of publication: |
2019
|
---|---|
Authors: | Knox, Colin ; Janenova, Saltanat |
Published in: |
International Journal of Public Sector Management. - Emerald, ISSN 0951-3558, ZDB-ID 2032073-5. - Vol. 32.2019, 6 (02.08.), p. 600-615
|
Publisher: |
Emerald |
Saved in:
Online Resource
Saved in favorites
Similar items by person
-
The politics of pension reforms in Kazakhstan: pressures for change and reform strategies
Maltseva, Elena, (2019)
-
Development evaluation in authoritarian states : A case from Kazakhstan
Knox, Colin, (2020)
-
Local government expenditure in Northern Ireland
Knox, Colin, (1991)
- More ...