WHY UNDERSTANDING SMOKING BANS IS IMPORTANT FOR ESTIMATING THEIR EFFECTS: CALIFORNIA'S RESTAURANT SMOKING BANS AND RESTAURANT SALES
"A large literature has sought to determine whether smoking bans help or hinder restaurants. Much of the literature improperly specifies its econometric equations and thus mistakenly infers causality. Examining the relationship between restaurant smoking bans and restaurant revenues in 267 California communities, we reach two main conclusions. First, California's municipal restaurant smoking bans are endogenous in a critical way-restaurant sales growth (or something correlated with restaurant sales growth) appears to cause restaurant bans, not vice versa. Consequently, failure to control properly for trends can produce spurious "evidence" of causation. Second, ban heterogeneity (e.g., state versus local) can be exploited to sort out-or rule out-causal effects. In other words, pooling data and treating smoking bans implemented at different levels as homogenous (as many studies do) ignores an important source of information and is likely to lead to erroneous conclusions. Our analysis holds lessons for the many studies that have examined the arguably more important question of how smoking bans affect smoking rates. "("JEL "L51) Copyright (c) 2008 Western Economic Association International.
Year of publication: |
2008
|
---|---|
Authors: | FLECK, ROBERT K. ; HANSSEN, F. ANDREW |
Published in: |
Economic Inquiry. - Western Economic Association International - WEAI, ISSN 0095-2583. - Vol. 46.2008, 1, p. 60-76
|
Publisher: |
Western Economic Association International - WEAI |
Saved in:
freely available
Saved in favorites
Similar items by person
-
Fleck, Robert K., (2008)
-
The origins of democracy : a model with applications to ancient Greece
Fleck, Robert K., (2006)
-
Repeated adjustment of delegated powers and the history of eminent domain
Fleck, Robert K., (2010)
- More ...