In the past decade, consumer psychology has experienced a crisis of confidence. Research in our field has rightfully been criticized for p-hacking, Hypothesizing After the Results are Known, and other practices that lead to overestimation of the reliability and replicability of published...

We distinguish two kinds of theoretical contributions that can be made in empirical research: new claims about links between unobservable constructs and new claims to explain important stylized facts about relations between observable real-world phenomena, termed “phenomenon-to-construct...